Informed Comment

Thoughts on the Middle East, History, and Religion

Juan Cole is President of the Global Americana Institute

Wednesday, August 29, 2007

Shiite Militia Clashes at Karbala Killl 52, Wound 206
Mahdi Army Rampage against SIIC offices in Baghdad

Clashes between rival militias in the Shiite holy city of Karbala left some 52 dead and 206 wounded on Tuesday, according to late reports from Iraqi security officials. About a million Shiite pilgrims had converged on the city to commemorate the birthday of the Twelfth Imam, the 12th in the line of succession from the Prophet Muhammad, who Shiites expect to appear supernaturally at the end of days.

The fighting let the government to declare a curfew and to insist that the pilgrims disperse. The government sent some buses from Baghdad. Reuters says its stringers in Karbala identified the two sides as the Mahdi Army of the Sadr Movement and the Badr Corps of the Supreme Islamic Iraqi Council (SIIC). Three hotels in downtown Karbala were burned in the disturbances.

Al-Zaman reports in Arabic two stories about what happened. The first is a somewhat implausible story that Iraqi police just began firing at the pilgrims indiscriminately when they chanted slogans criticizing the government of Nuri al-Maliki for its repressive policies in the south.

So what's going on here? The Supreme Council controls the shrine and mosque of Imam Husayn in Karbala, among the holiest shrines in the Shiite world. Pilgrims give donations when they visit the shrine, worth millions every year, and being able to preach at its mosque lends prestige to the incumbent. Al-Zaman says that the Sadrists, which in 2003 for a while controlled the shrine, were using the cover of the enormous crowds to steal a march on the Badr Corps, seeking to occupy the shrine. Badr appears to have fought them off. A lot of Karbala police were recruited from Badr, so it is always hard to tell militia on militia violence from police on militia violence.

That the Shiite government of Nuri al-Maliki cannot maintain order in the supremely Shiite city of Karbala during a major holy rite is very worrisome. In a way, Karbala's violence during the past two days reminds me of the Shiite on Shiite violence in Basra. The south seems less and less stable, as the Mahdi Army and the Badr Corps square off against one another, each seeking to control as many provinces as possible.

Leaders of the Mahdi Army and the Supreme Council in Karbala were said to be meeting urgently with the Shiite Grand Ayatollahs in an effort to find a way to get the two groups to stop fighting.

Al-Zaman reports in Arabic that Mahdi Army elements attacked offices of the Supreme Council in several places in Iraq in reprisal for SIIC fighting with the Mahdi Army in Karbala. McClatchy reports of these clashes:


'Gunmen broke in the office of Supreme Islamic Iraqi Council (SIIC) in Kadhemiyah neighborhood north Baghdad around 5,00 pm and kidnapped 4 guys and burnt the office. . .

5 people killed and 20 injured in clashes between gunmen and guards of an office of the Supreme Islamic Iraqi Council (SIIC) in Habibiyah neighborhood east Baghdad. The clashes broke out around 6,00 pm and still ongoing.

Gunmen attacked the office of SIIC in Amil neighborhood southwest Baghdad around 7,30. The clashes stills ongoing and no casualties reported.

Gunmen attacked the office of the SIIC in Husseiniyah town north Baghdad around 7,30 Pm. No casualties reported.'


McClatchy rounds up other political violence in Iraq for Tuesday. Sunni Arab guerrillas were attacking Shiite pilgrims. There are all these underground wars in Iraq.

' Baghdad: 4 pilgrims were wounded when gunmen attacked them in AlBo’etha area south Baghdad around 7,30 am. . .

6 pilgrims were injured when gunmen attacked them in Mahmoudiyah town south Baghdad around 7,45 am. . .

A civilian was killed and 3 others wounded in a parked car bomb explosion in Sheikh Omar neighborhood downtown Baghdad around 10,30 am. . .

Gunmen broke in the mosque of Haj Isma’il in Qahira neighborhood north Baghdad around 5,00 pm killing 3 men and kidnapping another 3 men . . .

Police found 13 unidentified bodies in Baghdad today. . .

Labels:

5 Comments:

At 3:43 AM, Blogger Christiane said...

That the Shiite government of Nuri al-Maliki cannot maintain order in the supremely Shiite city of Karbala during a major holy rite is very worrisome.

The US is the occupier. So the US army is responsible for security in Iraq. Al'Maliki's government doesn't even have the authority to order anything to the Iraqi army without US approval (he has already bitterly complained about it). So why join the choir of US Bush/Clinton criticism on Al'Maliki ? He is just a fig leaf for the US occupation; in reality, the US has destroyed the Iraqi government structures, so how can you ask that he governs ?

 
At 5:03 AM, Anonymous Anonymous said...

".......The problem with the two leaders talking big against one another is that the provocations might suddenly get out of hand and suddenly there would be a war......."

Bush and Sarkozi are damm lucky (so as us good humans) to have nice leaders in Tehran, wise, patient and mature enough to listen endlessly to the crap they shell out daily. What a great Islamic Leadership, Moslems are really blessed to had have them in power and leadership position at this right moment in history.

But I know the Jewish Pyramid Scheme is already busted and they have no choice but to go forward with war with Iran, so that all those "Goyyeems" in the world can finally be numbered and chipped in the right hand like farm animals. That is really what is it all about, averting the total collapse of that Jewish Pyramid game they played for centuries and unfortunately that will also require a War with Russia and another with China.

Why have not Bush and the Western World made a fuss about the Nukes stashed in Demona desert, in Pakistan or India, South Africa and others. Why Iran peaceful program for energy is such an “Unacceptable” as Sarkozi said? Iran already has severe energy shortage and rationing it this years caused riots in the streets.

I am so happy I live in a period of time to see all those evil ones finally destroyed by god as he promised for ages. He declared in the Bible: “ I shall put hooks in the jaws of Gog (England-France-Spain) and Magog (America) and drag them to the battle of Armageddon, smash them against the mountain” God will utterly destroy them so humans can look up to heaven and say GOD IS GREAT. God also said: in that day” WOW unto Jacob, for his children will see a day of trouble like no other” It is all coming to fulfillment.

God created mankind as free and sovereign willed, the Jews installed oppressive puppet governments and wanted to enslave and number all human Goyyeems, they did not heed the warning when he slaughtered all the Jews of Israel sheep’s because they tagged them and they learned nothing for being numbered in Auschwitz, no repentance.

 
At 9:36 AM, Anonymous Anonymous said...

"Leaders of the Mahdi Army and the Supreme Council in Karbala were said to be meeting urgently with the Shiite Grand Ayatollahs in an effort to find a way to get the two groups to stop fighting."

Professor Cole, what do you think the chances are these militias will stop attacking each other if the US starts dropping bombs on Iran?

 
At 2:11 PM, Blogger Ralph Dratman said...

Do you have any concerns that a "rogue faction" could be directly or indirectly sponsored by the U.S. in an attempt to sow discord?

 
At 7:22 PM, Anonymous Anonymous said...

The Mahdi army has apparently divided into factions and so is the likely source for starting the shooting in Karbala. The US military likely had some advisors standing by in Karbala, but the Iraqi security forces were expected to control the millions of people that had been anticipated. I haven't read of any US troops even patrolling in Karbala - they are stationed considerably north-east of there.

Also all those continually arguing about US "occupation" and "colonialism" can't explain why there are few coalition troops in Basra province where some 85-90% of Iraq's oil and gas reserves connect. The pipelines mostly connect in Basra itself which coalition forces don't even control any more.

 

Post a Comment

<< Home