Informed Comment

Thoughts on the Middle East, History, and Religion

Juan Cole is President of the Global Americana Institute

Wednesday, August 22, 2007

Bush, Sistani back off Support for al-Maliki;
Iraq, Syria, seek Energy Cooperation

When pressed on the future of Prime Minister Nuri al-Maliki, Bush declined to back him as forcefully as in the past. He said it was up to the Iraqis to decide. I don't think things look good for al-Maliki.

Al-Quds al-`Arabi [pdf] reports in Arabic that Grand Ayatollah Ali Sistani is "disgusted" with the al-Maliki government. He complains that it has 'filled his heart with pus' by donning his robes and then neglecting to establish security or provide services to the people.

If Sistani has soured so badly on al-Maliki, he really could be in trouble. The old man still has enormous moral authority.

And, if both Bush and Sistani have given up on him, it is hard to see how he can survive.

Residents of the city of Khalis staged a big demonstration against the lack of security and constant mortar barrages. When a US convoy came through, they maintain, the soldiers tried to disperse their demonstration and wounded 17 or so persons with gunfire. The US military denies it. After the convoy left, the demonstration continued. This incident is a little window into what the Iraqi street is thinking, which is that the al-Maliki government and the US military owe them security, and they aren't receiving it from them.

Alexandra Zavis of the LA Times has a truly excellent report on Dora district in Baghdad, where Sunni Arab guerrillas are under siege by the US military and fear Shiite encroachments from the east. Getting a story like this in present circumstances was no easy thing and we have seen relatively little recent reporting from the ground. The article shows clearly the conceptual confusion in the US military, of seeing Dora-based militants as "al-Qaeda" and as foreign to the neighborhood. Many of the guerrillas are mostly just local good ol' boys, folks, and that is the reason they can hide so effectively from the US in their daytime civvies.

Al-Hayat reports in Arabic that, as expected, the deal offered to Iraqi Prime Minister Nuri al-Maliki was more security in return for greater economic cooperation. (See also the OSC press summary below).

UPI reports that the cooperation focused on reviving the oil pipeline from Iraq through Syria, and on linking Iraq to the Syrian (and Arab) gas pipeline network. It should be noted that if the Syrian oil pipeline could be reopened, the tolls would amount to hundreds of millions of dollars a year for Damascus. In a good year, the Iraqi petroleum pipeline was worth a billion dollars a year to Turkey.

Oil Minister Hussein Shahristani has overseen the building of a new pipeline to Turkey through northern Iraq, which will be guarded by a new protection force, and Iraq hopes also to begin pumping from the Kirkuk fields again soon. I suppose the success or failure of this effort would tell us whether the revival of the Syrian pipeline is feasible.

A Sunni family of 7 was brutally cut down on Tuesday in Mahaweel by (presumably) a Shiite death squad. A lot of the ethnic feuding in Iraq has been caused by Saddam Hussein's Arabization programs, of planting Sunni Arab populations in Shiite or Kurdish areas. Northern Babil province is like that. The displaced Shiites have come back for their old land and homes, and want to chase the Sunni Arabs out of them. Now, establishing a Sunni Arab ring around south and west Baghdad is important to the Sunni Arab guerrillas, while Shiite militias want to extend their sway north from Hilla. Competition over land and resources was also important to the Sunni Arab guerrilla bombings of those Yazidi villages, where McClatchy says the stench of death still hangs in the air.

DPA/ VOA report:


In political developments, the so-called Sadrist bloc, loyal to Shiite radical cleric Moqtada al-Sadr, proposed Tuesday a new political initiative that could possibly end country's impasse, a Sadrist legislator told VOI.

The Sadr bloc have walked out of Premier Nuri al-Maliki's cabinet after the latter failed to force the US military to set a timeline for withdrawal.

"The initiative rests on collective participation and is composed of a consultative body to consider critical decisions in the country," Falah Shanshal said.

"The body would comprise 15 persons from all political groups based on parliamentary representation," he added.

He claimed that their initiative so far have been met with approval by most representatives of the political blocs.

"All minorities will be represented in this suggested consultative body," Shanshal said, adding that the decisions of the body, which will mainly monitor the work of state institutions, would be debated in parliament or by the cabinet."


At the Napoleon's Egypt blog: "Bonaparte orders Dissidents Beheaded." And we thought beheading was only something al-Qaeda does.

At the Global Affairs Blog, the USG Open Source Center summarizes Taiwanese reports on economic development in Kyrgyzstan & Uzbekistan and on geopolitical rivalry over Central Asia between Russia, China and the US.

Labels:

13 Comments:

At 4:44 AM, Blogger Unknown said...

Dear Juan,

you wrote:

"A lot of the ethnic feuding in Iraq has been caused by Saddam Hussein's Arabization programs, of planting Sunni Arab populations in Shiite or Kurdish areas."

But you know that, at least for Sunnis-Shiites, there is not an ethnic difference.

It is a little bit like in Yugoslavia, that you often cite too.

It is religious traidional differences, that some years ago were mattering nil to the very most of population, that are used as propaganda excuse for:

-first) arming thugs
-then) spread hate via the actions of thugs
-later) break a nation and enjoy power and richness

This has to do with international pillage by foreign powers, with the "grand game", and with religious leaders that, as in any historical precedent, are willing and eager to bless their "religious" troops.

You seem to have been in Iraq, and probably you have been in Yugoslavia, but you keep to bow (now and then) to the burden of white man confronted to "ethnic" cleansing.

This is a Democratic (as in the USA political party) reflex to long for an "humenitarian" war.

But you know too well that Canada and Mexico, after some years of sanction against USA, can be able to sponsor "ethnic" warfare with religious propaganda arming the tugs to have a Christian Fundamentalists against Catholics against Islamist in USA, make the major cities collapsing and the countryside a hell of "ethnic cleansing".

But you know this has nothing to do with etnicity and religion. As never a war had such a cause.

Don't you?

Thanks for your daily reporting and documenting about Iraq and for the collective blog!!!!

Keep the good work, we all like it!

Giovanni

 
At 10:50 AM, Blogger Da' Buffalo Amongst Wolves said...

Here's some good news from InsideHigherEd:

Haleh Esfandiari, director of the Middle East Program at the Woodrow Wilson Center for Scholars, was released on bail from a prison in Iran Wednesday, Reuters reported. Esfandiari, an Iranian-American, was visiting her mother when she was arrested in May and charged with espionage — a charge viewed by her scholarly colleagues as clearly absurd. Reuters quoted Esfandiari’s lawyer as saying that she would be able to leave the country. The Wilson Center, which has been involved in efforts to free Esfandiari, has maintained a Web site with extensive information on the case.

[src], with links

 
At 11:39 AM, Anonymous Anonymous said...

RE: "And, if both Bush and Sistani have given up on him, it is hard to see how he can survive."

Indeed. A few weeks ago, PM al-Maliki went to Iran and was photographed there smiling and holding hands with President Ahmadinejad. Intended or not, this was a clear middle finger salute to the Great White Father in Washington. There are some things a wise client doesn't do, and embarrassing his alpha patron is one of them. In his defense, al-Maliki may listen to Bush's many glowing words about bringing democracy to Iraq and naively think he is talking about Iraqi self-determination. Grow up, Nuri! Somebody needs to send this guy a copy of "The Godfather" so he can begin to understand the nature of a patron-client relationship-- while he is still sucking air.

 
At 1:03 PM, Blogger Margaret said...

Juan,

Bushco is successfully promulgating the "progress in Iraq" meme. Even a Democratic opponent of the war and the surge (voted against both; didn't catch his name) said yesterday on NPR that after just coming back from Iraq, he thinks "progress is being made" and it would be a humanitarian disaster to pull out now.

Polls show that an increasing percentage of Americans think the surge was the right thing to do and overall "progress is being made".

Bush recommends patience and it seems everyone is agreeing with him. I hear one or two dissenting reports on NPR but mostly it's all agreeing that violence is down, "progress is being made".

Bush's speech to the Veterans of Foreign Wars was disgusting. "This enemy will be defeated." (What enemy was that, again?)

Now al-Maliki says he can find other allies than America...

What do you think is going to happen?

Margaret

(And PS: has anyone heard from Riverbend?)

 
At 1:10 PM, Anonymous Anonymous said...

"...And, if both Bush and Sistani have given up on him, it is hard to see how he can survive..."

Don't worry about him, it is the Middle East, his son and grandson will be in the same office. Even they actually were ordering and doing all the killing and stashing all the Iraqi oil cash. Do you want examples? LOL

 
At 1:29 PM, Anonymous Anonymous said...

The article by Zavis in the LA Times does not say what you claim it does. In fact it puts most of the blame of the problems on the militants and does not make a clear distinction of whether they are local kids or "Al-Qaeda foreign" fighters. It is another whitewash of the crimes of the US occupation in my opinion.

 
At 1:34 PM, Anonymous Anonymous said...

What the Bush administration seems to want is greater sectarian "integration" of the Iraqi Army, less discrimination against Sunni's by the government, and an oil law passed by the parliament. However if Maliki came to a political agreement with Moqtada al-Sadr, it would likely be looked on extremely poorly by the Bush administration.

Also in addition to an agreement opening the Iraq-Syria pipeline that Juan covered, there was an agreement with Syria to build a new natural gas pipeline from an Iraqi gas field near the north-east Syrian border. Europe is of course keenly interested in alternate sources of natural gas. Also Syria has apparently refused to forgive Iraqi debt, so potentially the "economic agreements" signed by Maliki might have dealt with that.

 
At 1:55 PM, Blogger Sulayman said...

Amazing, after the US pulled all those strings to unseat Maliki's predecessor and install him.

The US puts a lot of pressure on governments, then boldly denies doing so. Thousands in Pakistan are missing after the government rounded up dissidents and suspected Al-Qaeda people at the behest of the US. When asked to comment, the White House deemed it an "internal Pakistani matter."

 
At 2:58 PM, Blogger eurofrank said...

Dear Professor Cole

I listened to the Audio of Young Mr Bush's speech today on BBC radio.

He talked about all the useful things his fine friend Mr Maliki could do.

Top of the list "pass an oil law".

 
At 3:32 PM, Blogger eurofrank said...

For a British Historian's view on Young Mr Bush's Phillipic.

Corelli Barnet


Choose the Americans React option

 
At 7:26 PM, Anonymous Anonymous said...

Prof. Cole,

One of your London readers here. London reader who's in Boulder, Colorado at the moment. I'd very much like to read the Corelli Barnet piece you refer to but the link is kaput. Any chance it can be fixed?

Merci beaucoup

 
At 9:32 PM, Blogger Unknown said...

Hillary Clinton and the Imbecile Levin have called on Iraqis to replace Maliki. Hillary Clinton at her disingenuous, best is dire need of a do-over. Too bad there aren't any in politics


From the NewsHour Panel tonight:


GEORGE PACKER, The New Yorker: the government is, as one official said to me, not dysfunctional, it's nonfunctioning. It is practically collapsed.

"We're not hearing the whole story"

RAY SUAREZ: Well, Laith Kubba, are we now hearing in public things that were already being said in private for weeks, maybe months?

LAITH KUBBA, Former Iraqi Government Spokesman: I think we're not hearing the whole story. I think the frustration with Maliki and his government is real, and it's understandable, and Iraqis have been frustrated for awhile.

I think what we're not hearing is that the problem is not with the person. If you replace Maliki with any other person, those problems will not go. They're more rooted in a dysfunctional political system that needs serious attention.

 
At 1:00 PM, Anonymous Anonymous said...

For the London reader unable to link to the BBC report:

copy the link with a right-click.

paste that link into a new window

strip off everything except
http://tinyurl.com/2uwrqy
and hit enter

Dr Cole's oldest avid student

 

Post a Comment

<< Home