Informed Comment

Thoughts on the Middle East, History, and Religion

Juan Cole is President of the Global Americana Institute

Tuesday, July 24, 2007

Massive Bomb Kills 22, Wounds 60 at Hillah
US Blockades Mahdi Army
New Turkish Government may Decline Military Option



A suicide car bombing of a market in the southern Shiite city of Hillah killed at least 22 persons and wounded 60 on Tuesday morning. The northern reaches of Babil province are heavily Sunni Arab, and these have been waging a dirty war against Shiites. Most of their violence has concentrated on cities such as Iskandariya, but sometimes they have managed to hit as far south into Shiite territory as Hillah. This attack demonstrates that the Sunni Arab guerrillas continue to have the resources to hit Shiites, even in their own southern strongholds.

Also near Hillah, Sawt al-Iraq reports in Arabic that the US military took into custody the local Badr Corps commander. This Shiite paramilitary, a subsidiary of the Supreme Islamic Iraqi Council, was trained by the Iranian Revolutionary Guards Corps but has generally avoided conflict with the US forces. The reason for the raid was not reported.

Meanwhile, near Baghdad, US forces are blockading the Shiite Husseiniya district, in an attempt to crack down on Shiite Mahdi Army militiamen there. This article implies that so many civilians died after a US bombing of a paramilitary position this weekend because the guerrillas had stored explosives there and the secondary explosions took out surrounding houses.

A US push all at once against Mahdi Army, Badr Corps and the Sunni Arab insurgency could overstretch American forces and cause even more turmoil.

This article from the Independent underscores the new complications for Turkey's government of any cross-border raids into Iraq. It notes that 100 of the ruling AKP party's MPs are of Kurdish origin. In addition 24 Kurdish independents won seats. PM Recep Tayyip Erdogan may need their support to elect his choice of president.

I think the article errs in seeing the military as the main proponent of a hard line stance against the Kurdish Worker Party guerrillas (PKK) who have safe harbor on the Iraqi side of the border and have been attacking Turkish police and soldiers in Anatolia. The AKP politicians have spoken just as vehemently of a strike into Iraqi Kurdistan under certain conditions. And, their Kurdish-heritage MPs may have grudges against the PKK, which was known for hitting Kurds as well as Turkish authorities during its dirty war of the 1980s and 1990s.

Still, the article may be right that the outcome of the parliamentary elections and the new prominence of Kurdish representatives has reduced the likelihood of a hot war on the Iraqi border.

McClatchy depicts the competition between US and Iraqi forces in the wake of a Baghdad bombing.

McClatchy reports that 24 bodies were found in Baghdad on Monday, and bombings killed another two dozen persons in the capital.

In news I hadn't seen elsewhere, McClatchy says that 6 Kurdish troops were recently killed in Mosul. You wonder about the ethnic composition of the Iraqi army in that city.

Sawt al-Iraq writes in Arabic about the disappointing harvest in Dhi Qar Province this summer. The article blames the salinization of the soil and of the Euphrates itself. Peasants seem not to have had sufficient incentives to expand the amount of land cultivated. There were also problems with access to silos. Also, a number of key agricultural development projects have not been implemented. The article is not explicit about whether security is part of the problem. I cannot understand the problem of salinization of soil. In Egypt this has happened in the Delta because of the flow of the Nile slowing (as a result of the Aswan Dam), and the Mediterranean coming in as a result. But the Euphrates has not been dammed except at its headwaters in Turkey. Some observers think there will be water wars in the Middle East during the coming century. Anyway, I hope the shortfall in the harvest does not mean that Iraqis will have difficulty getting food. The four horsemen of the apocalypse seem to be stomping around the place.

Labels:

8 Comments:

At 3:38 AM, Anonymous Anonymous said...

Soil salinization is the result of water evaporation leaving the salts behind. It is a worldwide problem, which can be solved by washing the soil and draining it.

As for the Euphrates, there is a major dam in Syria close to the Iraqi border.

Rampant corruption is destroying everything in iraq, including agriculture. The disgusting Maliki is calling for "educating the people of Iraq on human rights" instead of facing any of the problems -- as if his victims are the problem not him and his criminal government.

 
At 4:07 AM, Anonymous Anonymous said...

Yes, the farmers of Iraq have faced increased salinity for many years, very surprised that you are unaware of it. It is mentioned as a problem way back in "Guest of the Sheik" - predates USA's invasion/occupation, predates Saddam's rise.

 
At 4:20 AM, Blogger Christiane said...

I cannot understand the problem of salinization of soil.

Salinization can be the result of evaporation (which means concentration of salted minerals it contains) and of anthropogenic activities, such as the use of chloride in industries and the use of fertilizers in agricultural lands. It can be the results of overusing waters in watering installations and canals. I think that in the case of Iraq, Turkey may be partly responsible for retaining a lot of water with big damns (this means less waters down in Iraq and thus greater occasions of evaporation). Then there is the possibility of overusing the oil in watering canals : each time the waters are deviated in water canals they cross longer distances and get more occasions of being contaminated by the salted components of the rocks, by fertilizers and longer time for evaporation. These problems of salinization of running waters aren't unknown. I remember having read that for instance in the US the Colorado river has to be desalinized before being allowed into Mexico. It's not impossible that Iraq had such treatment facilities for its water, but that they were damaged during the war (another gift of America to Iraq).

Also, at the beginning of the Iraq war, I remember the US making a lot of case about how Saddam Hussain had dried out the Marshlands in the South of Iraq, but I think that this was only part of the problem and that Turkey's damns explained the other half of the problem; the proof of it is that the marshlands could only be partly restaured after the damns built by Saddam Hussain stopped working.

(I'm a geographer, but specialized in human geography rather than physical geography, so this is mainly hypotheses; may be some Iraqi specialist can offer better informed comments on this)

 
At 5:52 AM, Anonymous Anonymous said...

Your respondents are quite right in general about salinisation, but less so about the specifics in Iraq. Salinisation in Iraq is caused by the high temperatures evaporating subsoil water, which, as southern Iraq is a natural desert, derives mainly from the Tigris and the Euphrates.

Everywhere you go in central and southern Iraq, you see white crusts of salt on the surface of the ground. The problem of salinisation is very ancient, and may go back to the third millennium BC. One theory attributes the decline of Sumerian civilisation to salinisation of the land (the Sumerian cities were in the extreme south between Nasiriyya and Basra).

Christiane brings up the other question of the marshes, and Saddam's efforts to dry them out. Behind that is a very serious decline in the quantity of water passing down the Tigris and the Euphrates, at least over the last 20 years. I haven't looked for statistics (are any available?) on the discharge of the two rivers, but looking at the latest satellite imagery, I would say that there is not more than half the water in the Tigris that there was in the 1980s. The reason is of course the three to four dams in Turkey on each of the Tigris and the Euphrates, one in Syria, and one on each river in Iraq.

As I mentioned above, southern and central Iraq is a natural desert, and depends on those rivers.

 
At 6:34 AM, Anonymous Anonymous said...

Salinization of the soil is a HUGE problem in Australia and may soon lead to the end of farming / agriculture on that continent. coupled with the extended drought, Australia is in a world of hurt.

Salinization of the soil is becoming more of an issue / problem in the usa, also.

Salinization of the soil is a major threat globally.

 
At 8:13 AM, Anonymous Anonymous said...

Soil salinization as a result of water evaporation in southern Iraq is a well-knwon problem, attested in texts as early as the 2nd millennium BC. So it is not exactly a recent evolution, but problems with the water supply and drainage systems evidently increase the problem.

 
At 3:20 PM, Anonymous Anonymous said...

Others have addressed most of the issues regarding salinization. Two additional points:

(1) The flow of the Nile is much greater than the Euphrates, which has only about a third of the Tigris' flow by the time it reaches southern Iraq. No tributaries enter the Euphrates downstream from the GAP project dam in Turkey, which means there's no new water entering the system to replace all the water removed by Syria and the millions of people using the river upstream in Iraq. The flow is not enough to leach out the accumulating salts in the topsoil in Dhi Qar. Simple mechanised irrigated agriculture as it is practiced right now is no longer sustainable.

(2) Most of the water flowing through the marshes is from the Tigris, not the Euphrates. The Greater Zab, one of the largest tributaries to the Tigris, is not dammed and its seasonal flooding is critical in preserving the marshes. If the proposed Bekhma dam in Kurdistan is ever completed, the marshes will be irreparably damaged.

On the issue of Turkey and the PKK in Iraqi Kurdistan - the victory of Erdogan really does significantly decrease the risk of a Turkish invasion. You may be overestimating the Kurdish MP's willingness to go after the PKK. Yes, the PKK has attacked many Kurdish politicians in Turkey. However, most Kurdish politicians see the response to the PKK as a political issue and not military one. The boundaries between PKK sympathizers and moderate Kurdish politicians are blurry. Support for the PKK in SE Turkey - or at least some of the objectives of the PKK - is far more widespread than most people realize. Few politicians from there believe that force is the solution to the problem. I think the election results are quite positive because Kurdish politicians who wish to advance Kurdish cultural and political rights within the framework of Turkey have more power than before. Hopefully common sense will prevail with respect to the futility of invading Iraqi Kurdistan. Turkish nationalists have for some time tried to pass off the idea of an autonomous or even independent Kurdistan in Iraq as an existential danger to the Turkish Republic. This is, of course, nonsense. Even if they win outright independence, the Kurds of Iraq can no more destroy Turkey than can a few female college students wearing headscarves. Perhaps the AKP leadership will be able to recognize that Kurds in Turkey will remain in the Republic if they are treated halfway decently, but that after nearly two decades of self-rule, Iraqi Kurdistan is a fact, and reintegration back into Iraq unlikely.

 
At 3:50 PM, Blogger paddyshap said...

Salinization cannot be just dismissed as yet another effect of global warming. While the climate change so affiliated with global warming certainly doesn't help existing river systems, it does not, in of itself, cause less rainfall. Instead, it causes that rain to fall in different places. Quibbling over semantics, I know, as the effect is the same for people dependent on river and rain-fed agriculture, but still...

As for salinization, it is as much a product of poor farming techniques as anything else. Over-fertilization and poor drainage are the most responsible culprits. If a farmer fails to drain treated water away from the crops after irrigation, especially water with far too many nitrates in it, the dissolved solids have a tendency to just sit in the soil, and over time, make it useless.

At least, that's my understanding of it.

 

Post a Comment

<< Home