Informed Comment

Thoughts on the Middle East, History, and Religion

Juan Cole is President of the Global Americana Institute

Monday, February 16, 2009

You Have Moved on, But the Injured and Burned Children of Gaza Have Not;
Call for Cyberspace Aid Convoy

The demonstrating crowds have gone home. The blog postings have tapered off. The pundits have moved on. Congress is back to its old tricks, ignoring public opinion in favor of the lobbyists and money men. The US public is worried about losing its job or getting back the one it lost. Gaza here is a dimming memory, a momentary nightmare now past.

But the Palestinian children wounded and charred by Israeli bombings are still screaming, their physicians unable to get hold of enough pain killers to still their yelps of pain. Some 5300 Palestinians, most of them children, women and noncombatants, were wounded in Israel's savage war on the Gaza population.



Please consider donating to UNICEF UK's Gaza children's fund (US UNICEF for Palestinian Children here). In fact, I challenge other bloggers to carry the same appeal for UNICEF, among the best aid groups for this purpose, so that we can see if we can create a cyberspace aid convoy for them.

I suggest that we use this icon:

and put something like "I donated to the Gaza Unicef Convoy and you can too" beneath it above our blogrolls.

Outgoing Israeli Prime Minister Ehud Olmert has ruled out allowing needed goods into Gaza, which Israel has virtually surrounded from land and sea, until Hamas releases captured Israeli soldier Sgt. Gilad Shalit. Olmert is thereby committing a war crime. You can't collectively punish the general Gaza population if you are the occupying authority. It is not allowed to torture that wailing child in the video above by keeping out painkillers, just because some adult somewhere from the same territory captured an Israeli soldier. But Olmert will get a pass on his war crimes. Apparently you only get punished for them if you are weak or lose; it isn't the crime but the power of the criminal that matters. I heard on LBC satellite news that Hamas replied that they think Shalit was killed by an Israeli bomb during the assault on Gaza. The Israelis and Palestinians are cruel to one another, in their taunts just as in their violence.



The United Nations Security Council again demanded that Israel let in food, medicine and fuel unimpeded. Since Israel is still technically the occupying authority in Gaza, insofar as it controls its borders and airspace, for it to engage in collective punishment on the Gazan population is a war crime forbidden by the 4th Geneva Convention of 1949, which was enacted to prevent Nazi tactics from being deployed against occupied populatoins. UN relief workers, have been impeded from getting into Gaza by Israeli authorities. Those who managed to get through found between 14,000 and 21,000 homes destroyed and 240 of 400 schools badly damaged. The value of the destruction is estimated at $2 billion, and the essential infrastructure of the Strip has been deeply degraded, with potentially severe human health consequences. Much rubble has yet to be cleared away, so there could yet be more dead bodies found, and bomb clearing has not been completed, so people may yet be killed by accidentally setting off unexploded ordnance.

It is often forgotten that about half of Gazans are children, because of the ongoing population explosion, caused by insecurity, which has brought the Strip's population to nearly a million and a half. When Israel made a total war on the Gaza population, it was inevitably targeting large numbers of innocent children.



Susan Taylor Martin of the St. Petersburg Times reports on the bewilderment of Fatah activist as to why the Israelis had blasted his house to smithereens. Fatah and Hamas have poor relations and Fatah has been negotiating peace with Israel.

Peace activists and Muslim groups in the UK are attempting to address the continued Israeli blockade of food and medicine by sending an NGO convoy of trucks to Gaza. They will go down through France and Spain, on ferries across the Straits of Gibraltar to Morocco, and then across North Africa to Egypt and the Sinai, hoping to cross at Rifah.



MP George Galloway is accompanying the convoy part of the way. He told the Independent,

' Anywhere else, there would be a Berlin-style airlift, he says. "Almost every window has been broken but Israel refuses to allow glass across the border. So, in the bitter winter, 61,000 families whose homes have been destroyed are living among the rubble and the rest are freezing because they've got no windows. You could solve that problem in a weekend, but because it is the Palestinians it doesn't happen."
'
The volunteers are taking their own aid. "What we asked people to bring was bedclothes, clothes, nappies, food and medical equipment." Does he really expect to be allowed in? "I do, actually. My prediction is that by the time we arrive in Gaza there will be a 12-month ceasefire." If not, they will wait there until let in.'


Galloway is pilloried by the British establishment as an exhibitionist, but he has a knack for speaking uncomfortable truths eloquently. He points out that given the magnitude of the humanitarian disaster in Gaza, the whole world would be doing an airlift if the victims were not Palestinians. As it is, aid for Gazans has arrived in Jordan from Chile and Pakistan. And the government of Scotland has voted to send substantial civilian aid.

Again, I say we create a cyberspace Gaza convoy via UNICEF.

Some American peace activists are beginning to organize for boycotts of and divestment from Israeli companies.



Boycotters maintain that some Israeli diamond enterprises selling in the US are morally compromised in two ways-- they import diamonds from West Africa (which can be blood diamonds, implicated in violence and human rights abuses), and use profits on selling the cut diamonds to support the illegal colonization by the Zionist far right of the West Bank. (All Israeli colonization of the West Bank is illegal, since it is occupied territory and falls under the 1949 Fourth Geneva Convention, which forbids the occupier to settle its own people in militarily occupied territory or to substantially alter the lifeways or conditions of the occupied population).

I think organizing an effective For America Peace PAC would be a thousand times more effective in putting pressure on Israel to cease its daily violation of basic Palestinian rights. But I also predict that Israeli Apartheid policies toward the Palestinians will deepen under the new, far-right government now being assembled, and that these policies will increasingly attract economic boycotts from the rest of the world. I think Israel is pretty vulnerable to such boycotts, though I think it will take 20 years for them to build up to the point where they have a practical effect. It is likely the next big thing.

On another cautionary note, the multinational audience in Qatar for the BBC Doha Debates (supported by the Qatar Foundation) voted that the Gaza war demonstrated that Arab unity is dead. The governments of Egypt, Jordan and Saudi Arabia deeply dislike Hamas, especially since it decided to play footsie with Iran, and those governments weren't exactly effective in protesting what was done to Gaza.

I don't think the big significance of the Gaza War, however, was political. It changed nothing politically. Netanyahu and the far right were ahead in the Israeli elections. They won. Hamas was in control of Gaza. It still is, and is now more popular in the West Bank and the Arab street, too. What has changed? The rockets still get fired at Israeli towns. Israel still occasionally bombs Gaza.

The big significance was humanitarian. So as to avoid negotiating with Hamas, the Olmert government made total war on Gazans, which is to say, on Palestinian children. They need our cyberspace aid convoy to begin healing and recovering. As things now stand, the Israeli blockade remains in place. Children in hospitals are screaming.

End/ (Not Continued)

22 Comments:

At 3:30 AM, Anonymous Anonymous said...

Re discussion of Shalit:

I remember seeing a piece in an online Middle Eastern news source, a couple of weeks ago while the attack was still underway, which carried a statement by Hamas to the effect that an Israeli soldier held by Hamas, who was moved to a new location after having been previously wounded in the air attack, was killed along with two or more Hamas fighters when an Israeli bomb destroyed their location.

The soldier was not named but earlier reports had disclosed that Shalit had been wounded in the Israeli attack, at which time Hamas said, "it is not in our interest for him to die in our custody" (or words to that effect) so they moved him to another location for treatment.

So the implication was that Shalit was the soldier who was later killed, and I was later rather surprised to keep seeing Israeli demands that he be released (as opposed to his body being returned). Maybe it's all psyops, or possibly it still hasn't been confirmed.

Peace,
Mary

 
At 3:41 AM, Blogger karlof1 said...

"The big significance was humanitarian. So as to avoid negotiating with Hamas, the Olmert government made total war on Gazans, which is to say, on Palestinian children." [My emphasis]

The pictures of Gaza remind me of Berlin 1945 or Tokyo, which is why I used the term Total War, and I thank you for finally using it.

 
At 6:44 AM, Anonymous Anonymous said...

The assumed deafness of US politicians and MSM on Gaza and the Zionist ideology has biblical proportions.
I am afraid the reaction to the on going genocide will also have biblical proportions.

 
At 8:38 AM, Anonymous Anonymous said...

You are surely correct that a powerful PAC would exert more effective pressure on Israel than boycotts, divestment and sanctions. However, most of us are not really in a position to organize such a PAC. Even if we are members of organizations which might be supportive, we seldom have power to move organizational policies. This is especially true in regards to this issue. Boycotts are things we can all easily do and we can ask others of our acquaintance to join us. Both are worthy strategies and should be advanced to the extent possible. As the movement towards boycott, divestment and sanctions gathers steam, it may well spawn the PAC you envision.

 
At 9:19 AM, Anonymous Anonymous said...

In addition it looks like Israel is facing a huge deficit:
http://www.haaretz.com/hasen/spages/1063183.html

The treasury would prefer to raise money by taking advantage of the rest of the $9 billion in guarantees granted to Israel by the United States in 2003, during the second intifada.

That gave Israel the right to issue $9 billion worth of bonds on the U.S. market, repayment of which is guaranteed by Washington. American backing for the bonds means that the interest Israelis have to pay on the bonds is as low as possible - just a hair above the rates on comparable bond issues backed by the Federal Reserve. Israel has used only $4.4 billion of the guarantees. The last time the state issued bonds in the United States backed by the guarantees was in 2004.

However, the United States plans to deduct $1 billion out of the remaining $4.6 billion, to punish Israel for its investments in territories beyond the Green Line.

 
At 9:21 AM, Anonymous Anonymous said...

Not to worry. All Zionist behavior toward Palestinians is pre-approved by Yahweh, who is, of course, a close colleague of Allah. I believe it was agreed some time ago between Yahweh and Allah that it would be agreeable, if not desirable, to treat each others followers in this manner. Not perfect perhaps, but worse by far is the abomination of western secularism, with its wildly outrageous notion that religious beliefs are a personal matter and that all religions should be tolerated peacefully. Secularism can only diminish Yahweh and Allah, a threat that both can clearly see. Hence, praise the Lord (of your choice) and pass the ammunition.

 
At 9:45 AM, Anonymous Anonymous said...

Thanks, as always, Juan. I just made a donation.

Pam Speir

 
At 10:05 AM, Blogger eileen fleming said...

Dear Juan,


Poets, musicians and photo-journalists have been expressing their broken hearts over Gaza on You Tube.

Please listen and view the just released Garth Hewitt song, "From The Broken Heart Of Gaza: Father Musallam's Letter"


http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=r5YCic77JHQ&feature=email



I am among many internationals now in process of launching the first electronic newspaper based in Gaza:

The Palestine Telegraph, which is dedicated to shattering the silence with the facts on the ground with hope we can affect the breaking of hearts [in particular in the US] and transformation of minds to understand that only an end to the occupation and equal human rights for all can provide security for Israel.

"We have seen the enemy and he is US"-Pogo


In Solidarity "We have it in our power to begin the world again"
-Tom Paine

Eileen Fleming, Author, Founder, Senior Correspondent WAWA:
http://www.wearewideawake.org/
Producer "30 Minutes With Vanunu" and "13 Minutes with Vanunu"

 
At 10:16 AM, Anonymous Anonymous said...

This is a superb analysis of the Israeli stated objectives versus the strategic and realpolitik results of the Gaza Ghetto attack and invasion:

The Futility of Operation Cast Lead

By Stuart A. Cohen

16 Feb 2009

....it is hardly surprising that within a few weeks after the formal cessation of Cast Lead (by which time, of course, Israeli townships in the south had been subjected to yet further bombardments directed from the Gaza Strip) the tone of [Israeli] public comment began to change. Some analysts now asked whether, once it had been unleashed, the IDF should not have been allowed to "finish the job" (presumably, by reducing even more of the area to rubble). Others, by contrast, wondered aloud whether the paucity of the results achieved by Israel did in fact justify either the amount of bloodshed that she had caused or the images of Gaza’s destruction that had been beamed around the world. After all, they argued, punishment on such a scale of severity – even when warranted by seven prior years of attacks on Israeli civilians – hardly reflects honor on its administrators.

Full piece Here.

.

 
At 11:05 AM, Blogger Unknown said...

It’s hard to watch the Middle East mess. Israel is committing moral suicide, using Nazi-style areal bombing of civilian areas and collective punishment methods, thus radicalizing the very people it claims it wants to negotiate with. I believe that the Israeli leadership has always been playing a shell game and was never serious about creating a viable Palestinian state. Today’s news of the seizure of West-Bank land by Israel, presumably to expand illegal settlements, is a case in point. Thanks for posting the donation link. When politicians fail civilians suffer. No more so than in the Middle-East.

 
At 11:14 AM, Blogger InplainviewMonitor said...

Put them to reservations

Of course, this is not an official position, but one can learn quite a lot about the actual Israeli plans from this article.

The idea is to put Palestinians to some sort of reservations (the term concentration camp is not used for obvious reasons) ran by Egypt, Jordan, Israel. My guess is, Western countries are also welcome to run these camps.

As for international law, it can be adjusted to make this enterprise perfectly legal.

 
At 11:17 AM, Anonymous Anonymous said...

I would like to see a flotilla of aid by sea, large enough and escorted by gunships to protect it.

Israel has the right to control its own border crossings and so does Egypt. It does not have the right to blockage Gaza by sea.

 
At 11:24 AM, Blogger Pedestrian said...

Gaza here is a dimming memory, a momentary nightmare now past.

It's not for all of us. I'm with CAIA (coalition against Israeli apartheid) and we in the student body are all over the University of Toronto 3 days a week. We're also working for Israeli Apartheid Week coming up the first week of March.

I know that our efforts don't add up to much - but I guess many of us struggle with this thought everyday: what can we possibly ever do that will add up to anything?

 
At 11:54 AM, Blogger easyplankin said...

This isn't over as a political issue, either. Like the Iraq war, it stands as precedent, for lawlessness, cruelty and impunity, until it is reversed as precedent.

 
At 3:26 PM, Anonymous Anonymous said...

I am puzzled by the link to the UK Committee for UNICEF...is there no US agency that can take donations without having to express them in pounds and incur currency exchange fees?

 
At 6:16 PM, Blogger Juan Cole said...

Hi, Helen. I could not find a dedicated Gaza appeal page at UNICEF USA, unlike the UK. I don't think there is a currency exchange fee if you pay by credit card or paypal, or at least no much of one.

Today, 1 U.S. dollar = 0.694540908 British pounds

 
At 7:20 PM, Anonymous Anonymous said...

Re the Gaza Census link, showing that 50.2 of Gaza residents are under 15 years.

That reminds us that well over 75% of the hundreds of Gazans killed as 'collateral' in the Israeli attack were not even MAM, military aged males. Being a male over 15 justify a random death or family impoverishment either.

Of course, IDF intel knows Gaza demographics as well as the locations of UN facilities. And 'collateral killing' cannot properly be applied to collective punishment of civilians by indiscriminate bombardment. Indiscriminate means knowingly killing civilians, even if combatants are targeted. It's homicide, of defenseless innocents And when many hundreds are murdered most publically in a time of war, that's a war crime. One of a magnitude that flows up the chain of command to Olmert and Livni. One that includes every officer that participates in the act or the coverup. Following orders does not make it into a defensive act.

US failure to back up our UN partners after their facilities and employes were targeted during collective punishment attack is looking like Sarejevo in 92-95.

Whether the half of Gaza war victims under 15 are the children of heroes or terrorists, the demographics predict a doubling of Gaza's population in the next 20 years, give or take. That bodes ill for todays 1.4M impoverished Gazans, and their Israeli jailers.

The solve for a high birth rate, in China or Gaza, turns out to be proper care of the children. The sooner meds, food, housing, education, and jobs get to Gaza, the fewer Palestinians will be sharing Isael's future as neighbors, enemies, or refugees.

Re Prof Coles point that the internal players and position remain much the same post-war in Gaza/Israel/W.Bank, the record shows that settlement of the conquered territory W. Bank continues under all Israeli governments. Todays anouncement of expansion of the E. Jerusalem belt settlements is no surprise. Eretz Israel was always about the Jerusalem myth.

I do have to question Juan's assertion that the divisive effect of Hamas and this Gaza attack on Arab regimes is unimportant. Hamas' link to Iran is nuclear Israel's greatest diplomatic asset; it goes to the strategic center of their battle to retain control of US policy.

 
At 8:11 PM, Anonymous Anonymous said...

For those of us in the US, US Fund for UNICEF did NOT run an appeal for the Gaza children (surpise!) However, one can still donate to their "Humanitarian Response in the Occupied Palestinian Territories" Fund:

https://secure.unicefusa.org/site/Donation2?idb=678155383&df_id=1861&1861.donation=form1&JServSessionIdr006=6187cqdfj1.app20b

 
At 9:44 AM, Anonymous Anonymous said...

InplainviewMonitor said...

"The idea is to put Palestinians to some sort of reservations (the term concentration camp is not used for obvious reasons) ran by Egypt, Jordan, Israel. My guess is, Western countries are also welcome to run these camps."

Expect KBR and Wackenhut to line up for these contracts, in the great American spirit of free enterprise.

 
At 2:09 PM, Anonymous Anonymous said...

Thank you for posting the UNICEF site. I just donated $25.00.

 
At 12:45 PM, Anonymous Anonymous said...

I wrote to the US UNICEF Committee to ask them why there was no campaign for the children of Gaza. Not to my surprise, there has been no answer.

 
At 4:57 AM, Blogger whypatcondellisntfunny said...

Thanks for this, I blogged the images and linked to this article. Let us build this virtual convoy.

 

Post a Comment

<< Home