Informed Comment

Thoughts on the Middle East, History, and Religion

Juan Cole is President of the Global Americana Institute

Saturday, April 19, 2008

Palestinian Children

Call me suspicious. Bound bodies found floating in a lake just don't seem to me very likely to be the victims of suicide. Riad's friend writes:


' A friend of mine, Austin middle-school teacher and pro-Palestinian activist Riad (also spelled Riadh) Hamad, was found gagged & bound in a lake. His death was declared by the local police to be a "suicide".

The story reeks of being either a hate crime or worse, an assassination by an interested party. Hamad's charity was under attack by various parties which volunteered to find links between his organization and terrorist organizations. FWIW, no such link has led to law suits against him, to the best of my knowledge.

Riad is no longer alive, but questions about his death (suicide?) seem very much alive. At the very least, a fair police investigation would be appropriate. Simply stepping up to people and killing them is not an acceptable way to shut down a charity in the U.S., I'm sure you agree. I believe that media pressure may be the only way to get a true investigation. If someone is killing Palestinian activists in the U.S., that must be stopped - somehow. '


Consider sending a gift to Save the Children and earmarking it for Palestinian children in the West Bank and Gaza. They told me you can't sponsor an individual Palestinian child, but that they do get relief to them. Some 20% of Palestinian children are being kept in a state of malnutrition by the Israeli occupation authorities.

I wrote about this problem 6 years ago. The situation has deteriorated sharply in the intervening period:

' A U.N. World Food Program initiative called Emergency Food Needs Assessment showed that 51 percent of Palestinians are food insecure in the occupied territory as a whole, with 70 percent food insecure in Gaza.

The main factors affecting Palestinians' access to food, exacerbated by the second intifada, are Israeli imposed restrictions on their internal and external movement. Limited Palestinian control over their natural resources -- in particular water and agricultural land -- is another major factor.

Furthermore, chronic malnutrition and dietary-related diseases are slowly increasing, WHO has reported.

Anemia amongst children age nine to 12 months stands at 69 percent in Gaza and 47 percent in the West Bank, with 33 percent of women of childbearing age affected. The number of cases of stunting, low birth weights and premature deaths is also increasing.

Some 70 percent of Palestinians are estimated by the United Nations Children's Fund to be living below the poverty line. According to UNRWA and the Palestinian Ministry of Social Affairs, the number of chronic poor has risen sharply. '


Please send those poor kids some money via Save the Children, which is very careful about how it reaches them.

Some 15% of Palestinians are Christian, and the Muslims believe Jesus was sent by God. I seem to remember Jesus saying "But whoso shall offend one of these little ones which believe in me, it were better for him that a millstone were hanged about his neck, and that he were drowned in the depth of the sea." If you aren't supposed to offend the little ones, I don't think you are supposed to half-starve them either.

14 Comments:

At 5:56 AM, Anonymous Anonymous said...

Front page today of the Independent in the UK:

http://www.independent.co.uk/news/world/middle-east/our-reign-of-terror-by-the-israeli-army-811769.html

An excerpt:

'Or using a 10-year-old child to locate and punish a 15-year-old stone-thrower: "So we got hold of just some Palestinian kid nearby, we knew that he knew who it had been. Let's say we beat him a little, to put it mildly, until he told us. You know, the way it goes when your mind's already screwed up, and you have no more patience for Hebron and Arabs and Jews there.

"The kid was really scared, realising we were on to him. We had a commander with us who was a bit of a fanatic. We gave the boy over to this commander, and he really beat the shit out of him ... He showed him all kinds of holes in the ground along the way, asking him: 'Is it here you want to die? Or here?' The kid goes, 'No, no!'

"Anyway, the kid was stood up, and couldn't stay standing on his own two feet. He was already crying ... And the commander continues, 'Don't pretend' and kicks him some more. And then [name withheld], who always had a hard time with such things, went in, caught the squad commander and said, 'Don't touch him any more, that's it.' The commander goes, 'You've become a leftie, what?' And he answers, 'No, I just don't want to see such things.'

 
At 7:51 AM, Anonymous Anonymous said...

Gaza is a genocide in progress sponsored by the USA tax payers. History will have no mercy on us. Cowardice will not work as defense.

 
At 9:18 AM, Anonymous Anonymous said...

God Bless you Professor Cole for telling the truth. God Bless You !

 
At 9:46 AM, Anonymous Anonymous said...

I'm quite certain than less than 1%of Americans actually read any historical documents, and histories including the bible and koran, etc.
I am regularly confronted with evangelicals and "christians" of all stripes who have no idea of the shared history and shared prophets of muslim and christian.
One would assume they are getting this incomplete picture from their preachers. Coversations start off with them as if they were very accepting of differences in religion and culture, but quickly devolve into rabidly militant, illogical, uninformed parroting of MSM "Hate"lines.

 
At 10:01 AM, Anonymous Anonymous said...

Carter defends right to meet Hamas

Carter said Palestinians in Gaza were being "starved to death", receiving fewer calories a day than people in the poorest parts of Africa.

"It's an atrocity what is being perpetrated as punishment on the people in Gaza," he said. "It's a crime... I think it is an abomination that this continues to go on."


N.C. congresswoman wants Carter's passport revoked

Earlier this week, she called for President Jimmy Carter's passport to be revoked because he met with Hamas, a Palestinian group that the U.S. government says supports terrorism.

"His actions reward terrorists, lend support and provide legitimacy to their belief that violence will eventually get them what they want," Myrick said. Carter could not be reached on Friday.


Sue Myrick is part of the Neocon mob. She's published for Family Security Matters, a subsidiary of the Center for Security Policy run by Frank Gaffney.

The CSP is the daylight, coffin home for leading members of the undead such as Richard Perle, Douglas Feith, and Elliot Abrams.

So now we have these Neofascist Neocons calling for President Jimm Carter's "papers"?!

Sue Myrick is running with the Neocons. Get a load of the Aryan logo on teh banner at FSM. It's like a page ripped out of Joe Goebbels' oeuvre.

Man Found Dead in Lake Claimed FBI Tracked Him

"We called the FBI and they said this is cost of business and would not do anything to help."

Austin Police Thursday afternoon preliminarily ruled his death a suicide. Hamad's body was found floating in Lady Bird Lake and had been bound with duct tape. Police say the binding was in a manner which he could have done it to himself.


Death Squads. Government run death squads. Just like Nicaragua and El Salvador. Labeled the "moral equivalents of our founding fathers" by a demented, senile b-movie star elevated as front man for the same damn crew.

The killer bees never made it from Central America, but the Reagan/Bush death squads have.

Shall we wait until Jimmy Carter's body is found floating in a reservoir somewhere, tentatively ruled a suicide before we remove our nation's enemies from Washington DC?

Where "impeachment is off the table?"

 
At 8:03 PM, Anonymous Anonymous said...

hi, I heard that two big orphanages were being cleared of palestinians in Hebron. Any news about this?

 
At 10:40 PM, Blogger Daro said...

Here's another story that won't make CNN

April 18th, 2008

At 3pm on Wednesday, 16th April, the mutilated body of 15 year old Hammad Nidar Khadatbh was found in lands of the illegal Israeli settlement of Al-Hamra by his father, who was out searching for his missing son.

Hammad had left the house at 9am on Tuesday, 15th April to work on the family’s land, located near the stolen agricultural lands of the settlement. As the second eldest son, he was picking cucumbers for the family rather than going to school, to help with the income of his struggling family. At evening he failed to return home, and so his father and other family members immediately went searching for him. They found nothing. They set out again the next day, Wednesday, and found his body in a place they had searched the day before - clearly dumped overnight.

Hammad’s body was naked, bloated, and tortured. His neck was broken, and his face had been smashed in with rocks. One finger had been cut off and there were multiple holes in his torso, seemingly made by a sharp, round implement - something like a pen, his family explained. An Israeli police officer who arrived on the scene to investigate the incident confirmed that Hammad had been murdered, but made no comment as to by whom. Hammad’s body was immediately taken to the coroner in Jerusalem, but the report on the exact cause of his death will not be available for another week.

After speaking to many people in the area, it was established that Hammad had tried to return home via the Al-Hamra (Arabic for "red area") checkpoint, but was refused passage through as being only 15 years old, he had no identification (IDs are only issued to Palestinians aged 16 years and over). It appears that Hammad was then forced to walk around the long way home, and was taken at this point on Tuesday night.

Given the location of the body - on settlement lands and near an Israeli-only apartheid road - the family are convinced that Hammad was killed by settlers from the Al-Hamra settlement. His father explained that his son was only a young boy, and had no enemies. Also, he explained, there are no Palestinians in that area, only settlers from the agricultural settlement.

The 11500 residents of the village of Beit Furiq, located near the northern West Bank city of Nablus, have regular problems with the illegal settlements near their village. Approximately three years ago a 78 year old man, Mohammad Abu Oday, was killed when settlers from Itamar settlement destroyed his head with large rocks. Another young man was also shot dead by settlers, and five others have been injured whilst attempting to pick their olives. Residents advise that these attacks happen when Palestinians go to lands that are anywhere near to settlements, occurring every couple of years.

Interestingly, these attacks elicit no repercussions on the settlers by the Israeli military such as are inflicted upon Palestinian villages in similar, or even lesser situations. The village of Beita, for example, was shut down for four days last week, with massive roadblocks installed on every road to the village, and residents arrested for attempting to leave after a shooting occurred near an Israeli-only road in which no one was injured.

Hammad was buried at 3pm on Thursday 17th April, and is survived by his parents and seven siblings.

 
At 10:46 PM, Anonymous Anonymous said...

Nelson... you're on it. Tax supported genocide.

 
At 11:11 PM, Anonymous Anonymous said...

Esteemed Professor Cole,

I note that this post, unlike almost every other posting you make, has no comments (since amended; no double post intended). The most glaring omission regards news stories over the years that have made it clear that the Bush administration has instituted a policy of being very unfriendly to Americans contributing to humanitarian efforts of which the Bush administration does not approve. One example is certainly association with organizations seeking to relieve the humanitarian crisis created and maintained by Israel on the peoples of Gaza. Americans of compassionate intent who draw no distinction between families in need stand a good chance of being elected to the ranks of "terrorist" federal No Fly list, plus other possibly excruciating impositions because King George II wishes to encourage the illusion that Gazans are less human than "us", and not really worthy of the quality of life "we" expect as due "us". Compassion is unAmerican in KG's stunted mind. Roll the calendar back sixty odd years and you will find similar feelings expressed by those who note the terrorist activities of the scions of the proto Israeli state. Israel will not be "free" until it acknowledges, no--honors-- those it displaced, in its fervor to "exist". It is long past time to differentiate between between the people of Israel, and the Israeli government, which in no way represents the population of Israel. There will never--repeat never-- be any security for Israel until this issue is addressed. The answer is simple: Do you wish to have honored neighbors living near you, or enemies. The Israeli government seems intent on wishing enemies on every border, forever. One must ask why. This is not a rational intent. People simply wish to live. This is not a koan. This is simplicity itself.

 
At 1:29 AM, Anonymous Anonymous said...

Many Americans not only don't read history, they have no idea of what is going on in the world today. (Rhetorical Questions) How many read "Informed Comment", watch Mosaic on Link TV or obtain information from any foreign news outlet? How many read McClatchy newspapers?

These same questions can be asked about the members of Congress and their staff... even those who are members of relevant committees.

One of my friends, who is originally from the Middle East, stays informed but it is extremely painful for him. He sees images of dead or damaged children and can't help but see the face of his own little ones. The only way he can maintain his sanity is to consider history and recall quotes like, "The powerful do what they can and the weak suffer what they must." Today he said something like, "Until now, throughout history, no one would say that Jews were brutes. That has changed. There were imams who risk their lives to protect Jews during the Holocaust..."

People I know who had figured out our government was dysfunctional decades ago are struggling to accept the fact that it is even worse. The Congress does not even try any more. The presidential campaign is covered as if policy discussions are rounds of ad hominem attacks... sports coverage is more fact-based.

This, alas, is who we are now. Even worse, it is not just us. Europe and the UK know better and they have a legal basis for making it very difficult for our elites to travel abroad. Status of forces agreements can be canceled. Charges can be filed. No nation has ever really put itself on trial. If other nations of the world want international laws to be laws, then they have do what is necessary to enforce them. Otherwise they are just ink on paper.

 
At 2:27 AM, Anonymous Anonymous said...

Targeted assassination perhaps? If so, that's quite a step - from Gaza to Austin, Texas.

 
At 8:58 AM, Anonymous Anonymous said...

Looked for the orphanages in Hebron, found this... my god... who can say that the Occupation does not make brutes out of the Occupiers?

Body of 15 year old Palestinian boy found mutilated in Israeli settlement
April 18th, 2008

At 3pm on Wednesday, 16th April, the mutilated body of 15 year old Hammad Nidar Khadatbh was found in lands of the illegal Israeli settlement of Al-Hamra by his father, who was out searching for his missing son.

Hammad had left the house at 9am on Tuesday, 15th April to work on the family’s land, located near the stolen agricultural lands of the settlement. As the second eldest son, he was picking cucumbers for the family rather than going to school, to help with the income of his struggling family. At evening he failed to return home, and so his father and other family members immediately went searching for him. They found nothing. They set out again the next day, Wednesday, and found his body in a place they had searched the day before - clearly dumped overnight.

Hammad’s body was naked, bloated, and tortured. His neck was broken, and his face had been smashed in with rocks. One finger had been cut off and there were multiple holes in his torso, seemingly made by a sharp, round implement - something like a pen, his family explained. An Israeli police officer who arrived on the scene to investigate the incident confirmed that Hammad had been murdered, but made no comment as to by whom. Hammad’s body was immediately taken to the coroner in Jerusalem, but the report on the exact cause of his death will not be available for another week.

After speaking to many people in the area, it was established that Hammad had tried to return home via the Al-Hamra (Arabic for "red area") checkpoint, but was refused passage through as being only 15 years old, he had no identification (IDs are only issued to Palestinians aged 16 years and over). It appears that Hammad was then forced to walk around the long way home, and was taken at this point on Tuesday night.

Given the location of the body - on settlement lands and near an Israeli-only apartheid road - the family are convinced that Hammad was killed by settlers from the Al-Hamra settlement. His father explained that his son was only a young boy, and had no enemies. Also, he explained, there are no Palestinians in that area, only settlers from the agricultural settlement...

 
At 5:02 AM, Anonymous Anonymous said...

In answer to a poster's request for info on orphanages, I read this only this morning on Smoking Mirrors blog which references the Desert Peace blog
http://desertpeace.wordpress.com/

From Khalid Amayreh in Hebron

Palestinian leaders and Christian peace activists as well as representatives of human rights organizations operating in the occupied Palestinian territories on Thursday made an impassioned appeal to “all men and women of conscience all over the world” to help stop Israeli army plans to close down and take over several orphanages and boarding schools sheltering thousands of orphans and impoverished students. Many of the orphans’ parents had been killed by the Israeli army and paramilitary Jewish terrorists, also known as “settlers.”

The appeal was made during a press conference at the main Girl Orphanage in downtown Hebron. The Israeli army has repeatedly raided the orphanages, boarding schools and affiliated institutions, vandalizing property, seizing food, cloths and shoes and confiscating several buses and cars.

The Israeli army accuses the Islamic Charitable Society, the largest and oldest in occupied Palestine, of teaching school children “radical ideas.”

However, the Charity lawyer Muhammed Farrah dismisses the charges as “a big canard and a blatant lie.”

“We have challenged them to produce a shred of evidence proving their claims. And so far they have failed to prove any of their allegations.”

Art Arbor, a Christian Peace-maker Team (CPT) member spoke at the beginning of the press conference, saying he was pretty sure that Israeli charges against the Hebron Charity were “baseless.”

“As a former headmaster in Canada, I can say I have seen here some of the finest students and teachers anywhere, I have seen good teachers and good students fully engaged. Last week I attended an English class where teachers and students were having fun, I saw teachers who produce students who will act to make the world a better place.

“But all this is threatened now. And I want to tell you that what the Israeli army is doing is not an assault on terror but an assault on innocent people who take care of each other.

“ In fact, it is the IDF that is engaging in terror and we are here to try to stop it.”

Taking the floor after Arbor was Nisreen Shawar, a local English teacher. She accused the Israeli state of waging “an all-out vindictive onslaught of smear, hate and vengeance against innocent Palestinians whose sole crime is their insistence on living and surviving.”

“We have been wrongfully accused of being terrorists and promoting terror. We are not terrorists, and we don’t teach terror. We are actually doing what school teachers all over the world do, namely making children better people for a better future. We teach kids to be kind, to tell the truth, to be mentally alert, physical sound and morally straight. We teach kids the same subjects taught anywhere in the world.”

Shawar compared the “terror canard against the Palestinians with the blood libel against Jews in Europe during the Middle ages.”

“The only difference is that these canards are now made by Jews in order to justify Israel’s slow-motion genocide against our people.”

Nago Humbert, Head of the Swiss Medecins du Mond Agency, lashed out at the immense brutality and savagery being inflicted on the Palestinian people by the Israeli state and army.

“Closure of schools, storming orphanages in the dead of night, destroying bakeries, confiscating food and clothes, throwing orphan kids onto the street…What is happening here? What is the lasting image Israel is going to leave in the minds of these kids when they grow up?”

Humbert, who spoke in French, said he couldn’t really understand what the Israeli army’s ultimate goal by acting in this manner.”

“How can we teach Palestinian children non-violence when Israel is doing to them all this, when Israeli soldiers are throwing kids from their orphanages onto the streets. Israel is destroying all our efforts.”

Paul Rehm, an American Christian peace activist from New York described the callousness inherent in the Israeli army’s assault on Hebron’s orphanages and other charitable institutions.

“How can we really relate to these callous acts, confiscating school buses, raiding orphanages and terrorizing innocent children?,”

Rehm quoted Martin Niemoller, the famous Nazi-era German priest, who lamented the German people’s silence in the face of the enormous atrocities the Third Reich committed in the course of the Second World War.

“When the Nazis came for the Communists, I remained silent; after all I was not a Communist. When they locked up the social democrats, I remained silent; after all I was not a social democrat. When they came for the trade unionists, I did not speak out; after all I was not a social democrat. When they came for the trade unionists, I didn’t speak out; after all I was not a trade unionist. When they came for me, there was no one left to speak out.”

Two representatives from President Jimmy “Carter’s Center” in Ramallah also showed up at the press conference and one of them delivered a statement from the former US President.

The statement urged the Israeli government to rescind military orders to shut down and expropriate school buildings, orphanages and supporting businesses.

Far from being fazed by nonviolent protests against its draconian measures in Hebron, the Israeli army last week stormed a bakery owned by the Islamic Charitable Society, seizing ovens and other equipments used to provide bread for thousands of orphans and needy students.

The occupation army also raided and weld-sealed a cloth-making facility employing grown-up orphan girls. Israeli soldiers reportedly warned the girls that they would be jailed for up to six years if they didn’t heed orders to leave the small cloth factory.

Palestinian leaders in Hebron have accused the Israeli state of “resorting to a dirty game whereby all they have to do to wreck a given Palestinian institution is to invoke the name of Hamas.”

“It is enough to claim that a given institution is associated with Hamas to destroy that institution. This is very much like Nazi Germany behaved toward political opponents prior to the Second World War,” said Muhammed Hirbawi, a Hebron civic leader.

Hirbawi said the Israeli occupation army was acting as a policeman, a plaintiff, a General Prosecutor and a judge combined.

“This shows that non-Jews can’t really obtain justice under the Israeli justice system. This is why the Palestinians need a third party to protect them from Israel’s wanton criminality.”

The Israeli army has not given really convincing reasons for its brutal onslaught against the Hebron charities. However, Israeli officials are saying privately at least that Israel is doing what the Western-backed Palestinian Authority wants.

Last month, an Israeli government official was quoted by the Israeli radio as saying that “what we are doing in Hebron is in the interest of (PA Chairman Mahmoud) Abbas.”

The PA denies any connivance with Israel against the Hebron charities.

end quote

Thank you, Juan Cole, for publishing on this. It is and has been causing me such distress that there are no journalists in the mainstream media calling the Israelis (IDF) to account for their inhumane and utterly immoral treatment of Palestinian people. This scandal, absent from the pages of any major newspaper, is a contrived onslaught designed to give the Israelis more than their fair share of land, resources, or even media attention.

Why is this? IMHO it promotes terrorism.

 
At 12:12 PM, Anonymous Anonymous said...

I am glad I found this page by chance (I was searching the web for ways how to support Palestinian children) and read all your useful comments. You might also be interested in this release regarding the situation in Hebron.

International NGO’s Rally to Rescue Hebron Orphans, by CPT Hebron, 10 May 2008


HEBRON


Representatives from CPT, UNICEF, UNOCHA, Save the Children UK, Defense for Children International, the YMCA, Relief International and other human rights organizations met in Hebron on 8 May to help Hebron’s orphans and students now living with the fear that the Israeli military will close their homes and schools. The representatives selected a core group of Palestinian and International NGO’s to halt the Israeli attack against Islamic Charitable Society orphanages and schools. The core group will also develop programs to ease the anxiety that’s been part of the children’s lives from the day the army first began its crusade.

Since issuing closure and confiscation orders against the ICS on 26 February, the Israeli army raided the central warehouse taking away school busses, clothing, food, stationery, equipment and other supplies intended to fill the needs of the children and their families. Soldiers have welded shut the gates of the nearly completed $2,000,000 Al-Huda girls’ school, raided and looted bakeries that provided bread to the orphanages and on the 1st of April, raided the sewing workshop in the girls’ orphanage, carting away sewing and processing machines, fabric, finished garments and office equipment...all of which they brought to the city dump.

Responding to an appeal filed by Jawad Boulos, attorney for the ICS, the commanding general said that in regard to the schools, orphanages and kindergartens, he “gives himself the complete right to take all necessary measures...if they continue to work in these facilities”.

 

Post a Comment

<< Home