Informed Comment

Thoughts on the Middle East, History, and Religion

Juan Cole is President of the Global Americana Institute

Sunday, April 29, 2007

9 US Troops Killed;
60 Killed, 170 Wounded in Karbala;
Over 60 Bodies Found;
Sadr Admonishes Bush


Iraqi guerrillas killed 9 US GIs on Friday and Saturday. Five of them died in active fighting in al-Anbar Province, which doesn't actually seem to have been turned around yet, unlike what is alleged in some quarters. A truck bomb attack had killed 10 Iraqis in the city of Hit on Friday.

Guerrillas blew up a market near the shrine of Abu al-Fadl Abbas in the holy city of Karbala on Saturday, killing a reported 80 persons and wounding 170. [Figures from Aljazeera early Sunday morning.] The sacred character of Karbala makes this sort of attack especially likely to provoke Shiite-Sunni tensions and violence. Wire services report:


' Television images showed a man running down a smoke-filled street holding a lifeless baby above his head. Smoke was rising off the baby. Ambulances had rushed to the blast scene in Kerbala, 100 km southwest of Baghdad. '


Reuters reports on political violence in Iraq on Saturday, revealing that "the war of the corpses" is heating up around the country. Some 17 bodies were found in the streets of Baghdad, victims of sectarian death squads. In the mixed city of Baqubah, 60 miles northeast of the capital, police found 27 bodies. In the northern Sunni Arab city of Mosul, police found 16 bodies. Other important attacks:

BAGHDAD - A roadside bomb hit an Iraqi army patrol, wounding two soldiers in al-Qahira district in northern Baghdad, police said. . .

BAGHDAD - Three mortar rounds landed in al-Resala district in southwestern Baghdad killing three civilians and wounding 10 others, including two children, police said.

BAGHDAD - A roadside bomb killed one civilian and wounded three others in Kadhimiya district in northwestern Baghdad, police said. . .

BAGHDAD - A roadside bomb targeting a group of day labourers killed one and wounded eight in the Zaafaraniya district in southern Baghdad, police said.

BAGHDAD - Gunmen killed five civilians and wounded one when they opened fire on their vehicle in Bayaa district in southwestern Baghdad. . .


Young Shiite cleric Muqtada al-Sadr called on Bush to acquiesce in the desire of the Iraqi people that the US set a timetable for withdrawal of its troops from Iraq.

In Islamic lore the Mahdi or promised one will return at the end of time to restore the world to justice. He will be opposed by an evil one-eyed figure, the Dajjal, which is usually translated the "anti-Christ" by analogy with apocalyptic Christian beliefs. Muqtada called Bush the Dajjal.

Muqtada's letter about Bush was read out in parliament by Liqa' Al-Yasin, female MP from the Sadrist bloc. The Shiite cleric called Bush "a great evil," adding, "Bush ignores all the calls asking for withdrawal or for the setting of a timetable for withdrawal, despite the demonstrations that the Iraqi people staged in Najaf and in every spot around the globe."

Muqtada addressed Bush, claiming that the UN had asked for a US withdrawal (not true). He denied that a US withdrawal would throw Iraq into greater chaos:
"What chaos can be greater from what we face in Iraq, in which blood runs every moment, without let-up . . ?" He asked if Bush had just traded Saddam's dictatorship for one of Shiite-hating Sunnis (nawasib) and excommunicators (takfiris). He asked what had become of Bush's debaathification, since he was now asking that Baathists be reinstated in the government. He taunted Bush for having announced an intention to disarm Iraq, complaining that Bush had filled "our beloved Iraq" with weapons. He asked, "How have you fought sectarianism, when you are reinforcing it by building walls and instituting partitions on a sectarian, political basis-- not on a national, Iraqi, Arab or Islamic basis.

Referring to the Democratic Party's dissent from Bush's policies in Iraq, Muqtada asked, "Do you want us to follow your mistakes and your plan, when you have yourselves turned against it? . . . What kind of democracy is this that you desire? Thousands go out to vote, then you go back to national reconciliation with Baathists and terrorists?

Addressing Bush, he said, "While you once predicted that your picture would hang in Iraqis' homes, now it is under their feet . . . You have destroyed the reputation of the West among Easterners generally." He accused Bush of having US troops put their feet on the necks of Iraqis, and desecrating the Qur'an.

He accused Bush of turning Iraq into an arena of contention. He said, "Bush, you wanted to make America more secure, but you have set it ablaze . . ."

Iraqi Prime Minister Nuri al-Maliki, speaking to a US congressional delegation, rejected US pressure and said that Washington's interference in domestic Iraqi political affairs was a "red line," the crossing of which he could not accept. The main issue that seems to have exercised him is US pressure on his government to change the "de-Baathification" process and to rehabilitate former Baathists (most of them Sunni Arabs) as public persons who can hold high government posts.

The oil investment law passed by al-Maliki's cabinet is also still getting a hard ride.

The LA Times reports on how security is deteriorating in Basra under the pressure of political and militia rivalries, leading to an increase in attacks on British troops.

Retired Lt. Gen. William Odom called on Bush to sign the bill specifying a US troop withdrawal from Iraq. Money quote:

' "The challenge we face today is not how to win in Iraq; it is how to recover from a strategic mistake: invading Iraq in the first place," he said.

"The president has let [the Iraq war] proceed on automatic pilot, making no corrections in the face of accumulating evidence that his strategy is failing and cannot be rescued. He lets the United States fly further and further into trouble, squandering its influence, money and blood, facilitating the gains of our enemies." '


Hmmm. I don't think Odom can be accused by the Republicans of being unpatriotic. He's not just some civilian politician. He isn't even a Democrat. He's a man of substantial military and intelligence experience. Certainly his credentials to speak on the impact of the war on the US military are impeccable.

In a video posted to the internet, an important al-Qaeda leader complained that the Shiites are not joining in the fight against the US but on the contrary are fighting al-Qaeda alongside the US. An anti-Shiite program is common among radical Salafis in Iraq, but had earlier been questioned by al-Qaeda leaders in the east.

Iraq's deputy prime minister, Barham Salih, will visit Iran in May.

Labels:

4 Comments:

At 6:09 AM, Blogger markfromireland said...

"BAGHDAD - Gunmen killed five civilians and wounded one when they opened fire on their vehicle in Bayaa district in southwestern Baghdad. . .

They were Red Crescent people Juan.

 
At 10:22 AM, Blogger Da' Buffalo Amongst Wolves said...

"He will be opposed by an evil one-eyed figure, the Dajjal, which is usually translated the "anti-Christ" by analogy with apocalyptic Christian beliefs. Muqtada called Bush the Dajjal."

Can't you smell the sulfur Professor Cole? Hugo Chavez could.

Here's a comment I've just posted to a list I inhabit about certain.... "personality traits"... among the people in the Bush administration that probably rubs al-Sadr, as well as the subject of discussion, the Saudi royalty, entirely the wrong way.

On 4/28/07, [REDACTED] wrote:
>

http://www.nytimes.com/2007/04/29/washington/29saudi.html

"For instance, in February, King Abdullah effectively torpedoed plans
by Secretary of State Condoleezza Rice for a high-profile peace summit
meeting between Prime Minister Ehud Olmert of Israel and the
Palestinian president, Mahmoud Abbas, by brokering a power-sharing
agreement with Mr. Abbas's Fatah and Hamas that did not require Hamas
to recognize Israel or forswear violence. The Americans had believed,
after discussions with Prince Bandar, that the Saudis were on board
with the strategy of isolating Hamas."
>
>

When you pressure people, they say yes, even when they mean no.

How do you think GWB managed to fail instead of grow his business ventures?

The hard sell.

A bunch of BS big talk that everyone shook their heads up & down to,
and then proceeded to do it their way if possible, or bail out of the
venture. Exactly as has happened with his wars.

The thing about the hard sell is it works with 'rubes'... like
Americans who Looooove football and consider murderous wars to be a
logical extension thereof.

But the Saudis aren't the 'rubes' they might have been in 1910 or so when the
first barrels of oil were exported, and the geopolitical playing field
has been redrawn (quite a few times).

But the US State department in
it's current incarnation is still (perhaps fortunately) reading a
playbook of domination written by the people just off the boat... the
Mayflower.

See: ""Our Indian Wars Are Not Over Yet"
Ten Ways to Interpret the War on Terror as a Frontier Conflict
By John Brown, USC Center on Public Dipomacy
http://leighm.net/wp/2007/04/08/gwot_indiwar_jbpdbr/

...for more on that, and some excellent comparisons.

I'm sure that the Saudi royalty considers most of Bush's people to be below dirt on the human evolutionary
scale...

 
At 1:13 PM, Blogger MonsieurGonzo said...

Professor, are there images available from the many (arabic, etc.) international news sources that you routinely translate, refer to here on Informed Comment?

iow, is it possible for you to illustrate your commentary?

 
At 3:40 PM, Blogger Alamaine said...

'Hmmm. I don't think Odom can be accused by the Republicans of being unpatriotic.'

A quotation attributed to H. L. Mencken:

'The notion that a radical is one who hates his country is naïve and usually idiotic. He is, more likely, one who likes his country more than the rest of us, and is thus more disturbed than the rest of us when he sees it debauched. He is not a bad citizen turning to crime; he is a good citizen driven to despair.'

LG Odom could never afford to be some sort of warped idealist when it came to warfighting; realism was his stock in trade. For those of us who have spent careers associating with military men and women, even whole lives in the company of those who have chosen military service as the highest calling, there is a patriotism that cannot be displayed by some little mystery mettle flag on a lapel or a removal decal for the car bumber. It is inside the body and soul, something that cannot be removed even through death, although the expiration of one's life is the ultimate display of dedication.

One considers the old Asian aphorism, 'He who speaks much knows little; he who knows much speaks little,' when thinking about those who are best able to be representive patriots. Those who are the most vocal about duty to country have been seen as those least inclined to put their lives on the line. Those putting their lives in harm's way are usually too busy doing the business of patriotic duty to sit around idly, running their mouths about things that are indeed foreign to them. Those most keen on war have been shown to be those least likely to participate in the prosecution thereof. They are left with little flags on their suits and decals decaying into dust to remind them that they are Americans. The military members don't have any of these sorts of memory gaps.

LG Odom (among vast numbers of others) is merely stating truth from experience, not from some pie-in-the-sky notions about what some nebulous desireable outcome should be. Even Ford shut down the Edsel plants when it became apparent that the product would not sell.** The ideas behind its marketing were fuzzy and not well-defined, its appeal creating uncertainty. Edsel's appeal did not satisfy even those who were supposed to put brand loyalty above all else.

Once more, H. L. Mencken:
'In the United States, doing good has come to be, like patriotism, a favorite device of persons with something to sell.'*

Indeed, the Billions of Dollars targeted at Iraq have been a boon for those in industries who would benefit the most. Needless to say, the military members see few of these Dollars, despite their moral rather than material contributions and comitments. Beyond 'selling' the operations as a consequence of 'WMD,' there have been other ruses that have been used to justify the operations' perpetuation. All the Dollars go somewhere, to someone, somehow excepting those doing the fighting and dying. Without worrying about the specifics of the expenditures, the Americans have been sold a giant lemon, a vehicle that they are expected to continue to maintain, treating it like some temperamental imported sports car (probably with English Lucas electrics {devised by the most unreliable of minds}), devoting innumerable hours and investing unnumbered Dollars in the process.

LG Odom understands that the most valuable thing is the life of the military, the lives of the members serving therein and therewith, their deaths in vain another example of the squandering of resources by those who have no appreciation for the the sacrifices involved. The heroes and heroines will go to 'Heaven' while those whose bank accounts will be enlarged will still be eyeing the needle.

'Suffering' by highly placed persons has been a topic of recent news reporting, something like the little mystery mettle lapel pins and the decoy decals on sedans. A buck-fifty seems to be a significant sacrifice for many who support the missions until the pins begin to chip and the decals decay. Again, their patriotism is externalised, their guts never having developed fortitude.

LG Odom (and all of us others) 'get' what it means to lose friends and loved ones, having put the effort forth to make the military what it is, not having relied on some guile or ruse to avoid serving nor trying at this late time in some peoples' live to rehabilitate their images through some devious devices or dubious devotion. War supporters should be the first ones to volunteer their lives and services; but, they have successfully taken up the rear (and on their rears), not differently from so many camp followers who have melted into the countryside once things got too hot, sweating bullets that they have otherwise successfully avoided.

* http://www.wisdomquotes.com/cat_patriotism.html
** http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Edsel

 

Post a Comment

<< Home